Key Takeaways

  • Construction and demolition waste media offer cheaper stormwater treatment than conventional materials.
  • Recycling and reuse pathways substantially lower total net present costs and treatment expenses.
  • Energy-intensive thermal processing makes traditional clay and biochar options significantly more expensive.
  • Operational parameters like maintenance intervals and replacement frequencies strongly influence long-term economic performance.
  • Secondary construction materials provide a circular, cost-effective alternative for decentralized Nordic stormwater systems.

A recent study in Environmental Technology & Innovation by Qaisar Munir and Timo Kärki presents an integrated techno-economic assessment framework to evaluate construction and demolition waste-derived filtration media for decentralized stormwater treatment and benchmark their performance against conventional filtration materials, including expanded clay, processed clay, and biochar, under harmonized Nordic operating conditions while explicitly incorporating circular end-of-life recovery scenarios. Under the harmonized base-case assumptions, construction and demolition waste-derived filtration media achieved approximately 19% to 70% lower net present costs and levelized costs of treatment than the conventional benchmark materials, depending on the end-of-life pathway and benchmark considered. Recycling and reuse further improved the economic competitiveness of the construction and demolition waste system through avoided disposal costs and recovered-value credits, with net present costs reaching €6,950 for recycling and €5,950 for reuse per filtration unit over a 50-year assessment period.

Traditional stormwater filtration media face several economic and environmental constraints that limit their large-scale deployment in sustainable urban drainage applications. Clay-based materials require energy-intensive thermal processing at kilns approaching 1,100 to 1,200 degrees Celsius, resulting in substantial embodied energy and associated greenhouse gas emissions. Meanwhile, biochar exhibits high cost variability depending on feedstock and production conditions, making it considerably more expensive than mineral-based alternatives. Furthermore, conventional media are subject to logistical and supply-chain barriers, including high transportation expenses, regional raw material shortages, and scalability hurdles.

To resolve these challenges, the researchers evaluated the valorization of construction and demolition waste fine fractions blended with low-density polyethylene through low-temperature thermomechanical agglomeration. This approach utilizes locally available waste streams with near-zero feedstock costs, avoiding the intensive energy requirements associated with kiln-expanded clay or pyrolyzed biomass. Although processed clay and expanded clay showed higher contaminant-removal efficiencies for heavy metals such as copper, zinc, and lead, construction and demolition waste-derived media provided a competitive balance between treatment performance, economic feasibility, and circularity potential.

The evaluation demonstrated that end-of-life management is a primary driver of long-term economic performance. While landfill disposal incurs a positive end-of-life cost burden, circular pathways such as recycling and reuse generate economic credits that reduce lifetime treatment costs to €0.28 and €0.24 per cubic meter of treated stormwater, respectively. Sensitivity and probabilistic Monte Carlo analyses confirmed that these cost advantages remain robust under simultaneous variations in operating expenditures, maintenance intervals, and replacement frequencies, positioning waste-derived filtration media as a viable circular strategy for Nordic urban water management.


Source: Munir, Q., & Kärki, T. (2026). Techno-economic assessment and system-level comparison of construction demolition waste-derived stormwater filter media with conventional alternatives. Environmental Technology & Innovation, 44, 105256.


Leave a Reply

Trending